Though it may seem like we’re all united against data center building, with residents concerned about water, energy usage and more, there’s a case to be made that they’re providing good jobs in the community—and labor unions are making that case.
Not very loudly, of course.
Data centers are wildly unpopular these days, and siding with them can seem like siding with the tech billionaires who don’t care about us.
“It’s just too easy for people to put everyone in a black-or-white, you’re for it, you’re against it, and if you’re anything but on my side, you’re awful,” said Charlie Wishman, president of the Iowa Federation of Labor AFL-CIO.
Felicia Hilton, assistant political director of the Mid-American Carpenters Regional Council, pointed out that data centers have been providing good jobs for thousands of Iowans for years.
“People don’t even know they already live around a data center,” she said. “We’ve been doing this for 20 years in Iowa. From Council Bluffs to Eastern Iowa, Central Iowa, from Microsoft, Facebook, QTS … We have about 12,000 tradespeople working right now in Eastern Iowa just on data center projects (and) energy projects.
“I don’t think that the approach is to stop it because, unless people are going to throw their cell phones away, I don’t see how it happens,” Hilton added. “It’s just going to go to Mexico. It’s just going to go to India. It’s going to go to China.”
But union leaders also say they hear people’s environmental and financial concerns, because they’re workers’ concerns too.
“If they’re going to be built, we want it to be done right, we want it to benefit the community, and we want them to pay their fair share,” Wishman said.
But those workers find themselves defending their jobs these days, seemingly on the wrong side of those concerned about rising energy bills, water quality, and more.
“Like, can you not yell at our men and women, like call them assholes and stuff, just ’cause they wanna like build a thing if it’s coming to town?” Wishman said. ”That was just really getting really frustrating because it’s not a us-versus-them, us-versus-a-community thing.”
Hilton and Wishman think both sides can meet in the middle by negotiating agreements with data center companies about those issues.
“We’re not here to say they should or shouldn’t be built. If a community doesn’t want it, it shouldn’t go there,” Wishman said. “ But if it is going to be built, we want to make sure that the community has a community benefit agreement.”
That could look like agreements surrounding water and energy usage, and who pays for what, Hilton noted.
“Each local government needs to be mindful of negotiating really good agreements,” she said.
Newer data centers, they note, use water much more efficiently, though energy usage has increased along with that.
But if negotiated well, they say, communities and residents can actually benefit from them—not only with more jobs, but with a company’s tax money in the community.
“I just want to have a realistic conversation about data centers because I think that communities can gain a lot out of this new industry,” Hilton said. “But I also get why they don’t like it.
“We don’t want to build anything that would harm our own families,” she added. “And we support the community wanting to come to the table to do that.”


















