The veneer of Joni Ernst’s farm girl image got pulled back ever further at last night’s Iowa Senate debate, revealing the foundation of a D.C. politician who lost touch with her roots long ago.
In what may go down as the defining moment of this year’s high-profile Senate contest, Ernst awkwardly bungled a question about farm prices while her opponent Theresa Greenfield answered a similar query with ease and confidence. Pressed what the breakeven cost of soybeans is currently, Ernst first tried to divert to a completely different topic, pushed back on whether the question was on corn, got the answer wrong, tried to blame Greenfield for not answering, got told she did, then passed on an opportunity to try again.
“You grew up on a farm, you should know this,” moderator Ron Steele of KWWL prodded after Ernst spent nearly a minute talking about trade deals instead.
“I think you had asked about corn. And it depends on what the inputs are, but probably about $5.50,” Ernst nervously replied.
“Well, you’re a couple dollars off, because it’s $10.05, but we’ll move on to something else” Steele noted in response, meaning soybeans.
“And I don’t think Ms. Greenfield answered either,” Ernst said.
“She actually did for the price of corn, we asked for the price of soybeans from you, Senator, do you want to take another crack at it?” Matt Breen of KTIV interjected.
“Uh, no thank you, you said the breakeven for corn was $10.50? I don’t think that’s correct,” Ernst said, adding that she wasn’t sure if she was hearing things correctly.
In Ernst’s defense, technical issues plagued the start of the debate, and there appeared to be audio issues for the candidates later on when this question was asked. Ernst appeared to be trying to answer the price or breakeven point for corn, but if that’s true, she got that wrong as well. A bushel of corn hasn’t sold for around $5 since 2013, a little over a year before Ernst went off to D.C., and the breakeven point has hovered around $4 or a little less recently.
Compounding problems for Ernst was that Greenfield knocked her answer on the question out of the park just a minute earlier.
“Well, a bushel of corn is going for about $3.68 today, $3.69, and breakeven really just depends on the amount of debt someone has. I suspect there’s farmers that are breaking even at that price. However, if their yields are down 50%, that’s certainly not going to cover it for them,” Greenfield succinctly said when asked about corn.
— Iowa Starting Line (@IAStartingLine) October 16, 2020
The exchange wasn’t a simple “gotcha” question, as it drove right at one of the main narratives of this race: who is the authentic, scrappy farm girl? Both Ernst and Greenfield have run countless ads recounting each of their upbringings on their family farms — Ernst in Red Oak, Iowa; Greenfield in rural Minnesota near the Iowa border.
It was obvious from last night’s debate that one of those candidates is still in touch with their rural roots and the current concerns of Iowa farmers: Greenfield. You could also see hints of the divide from the first debate, where Greenfield also brought up Iowa corn prices.
Heck, right now, a bushel of corn is about $3.30. That's going out of business prices. And that's because @joniernst sold us out when she voted for a fossil fuel lobbyist to run the EPA. #IASen pic.twitter.com/VkLoWhjFk6
— Theresa Greenfield (@GreenfieldIowa) September 29, 2020
Ernst talks an awful lot about traveling around Iowa to rural counties, but her struggle with the question makes you wonder what she has the radio tuned to on her drives. Commodity prices are constantly discussed on Iowa radio stations, and one would think that the senator would discuss specific prices with farmers when she’s out talking with them around the state.
Her campaign team seems obsessed internally with mocking Greenfield for growing up in Bricelyn, Minnesota, even though life five miles from the Iowa border isn’t markedly different from anyone living in Winnebago County, Iowa. If they were focused on more important things, like perhaps preparing a notecard of Iowa commodity prices for Ernst to look at before the debate, they’d be doing better in the election.
Ernst’s debate debacle will only further the view that she’s lost touch with Iowa after moving to D.C., more concerned with national Republican Party politics than the everyday concerns of her constituents. It’s the kind of thing that would lead her to vote for an anti-ethanol EPA nominee, just because he was the pick of the president of Ernst’s party.
Even the reason why Ernst got put in this particularly awkward position was due to her party loyalty over all else. Had Ernst been in the studio, like was originally planned, maybe the flow of conversation would have gone smoother, and she wouldn’t have looked this bad even if she did get the price off by a dollar or two.
Instead, Ernst was remote from D.C., where she was participating in a Supreme Court confirmation hearing she previously said she wouldn’t support, and the faulty audio feed tripped her up even worse.
There’s a word for that: karma.
by Pat Rynard
Iowa Starting Line is an independently owned progressive news outlet devoted to providing unique, insightful coverage on Iowa news and politics. We need reader support to continue operating — please donate here. Follow us on Twitter and Facebook for more coverage.
The Dec. 5 run-off election in Waterloo will be a match-up between a progressive voice on the city council who fights for LGBTQ protections and one...
More states are enshrining access to abortion care in their state constitutions, and some Iowans are wondering if the same can be done here? The...
Classic, vintage, iconic, and just plain cool, we found some old movie theaters sprinkled across the state—many of them long-time staples on the...
For 34 years straight, Johnny and Barbara Long never missed a West Des Moines City Council meeting. “They attended more meetings [in other years] as...