The 5 best pizza parlors in Iowa City, according to Reddit

If you’re a pizza lover, you’re in for a treat in Iowa City! With a dynamic food scene and a diverse range of pizzerias, the hunt for the best pizza in town is both exciting and delicious. What better way to uncover the top spots than by diving into the recommendations from Reddit users? From traditional recipes to creative culinary masterpieces, the pizzerias in Iowa City have something for every palate. Reddit users have weighed in on their favorites, and their insights guide us through this mouthwatering journey. Whether you’re craving a classic pie or something with a modern twist, Iowa City’s pizza offerings will not disappoint. Each spot brings its unique flair to the table, making the city’s pizza scene both rich and varied.

The Wedge Pizzeria

The Wedge Pizzeria is a standout in Iowa City’s vibrant pizza scene, capturing the hearts (and taste buds) of many with its inventive toppings and laid-back vibe. Step inside, and you’ll be greeted by a warm, friendly environment that makes it an instant hit for both solo diners and groups. What truly sets Wedge apart is their dedication to pushing the boundaries of traditional pizza. Wedge Pizza also excels in the crust department. Their crust is a perfect balance of crispiness and chewiness, providing an excellent foundation for their diverse range of toppings. Whether you prefer a classic cheese or something more adventurous, the crust won’t let you down. The enthusiasm surrounding Wedge Pizza on Reddit speaks volumes, and you can catch them at their new location in 2025.

Wig & Pen

Wig & Pen has become a local legend in Iowa City, and it’s easy to see why. Stepping inside, you’re immediately greeted with the cozy, pub-style ambiance that sets the stage for a memorable meal. Their dedication to using high-quality ingredients and traditional techniques shines through in every slice. If you’re in Iowa City and looking to indulge in some highly recommended pizza, Wig & Pen should definitely be on your list. The Reddit community’s enthusiastic reviews are a testament to the quality and flavor that this beloved pizzeria consistently delivers.

Maggie’s Farm

If you’re after a pizza experience that’s truly unique, Maggie’s Farm is your go-to spot. This place has won over Reddit users with its commitment to farm-to-table dining, ensuring every pie bursts with the freshest local flavors. Maggie’s Farm also caters to those with dietary restrictions, offering gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese options. With its ever-changing menu and dedication to quality, Maggie’s Farm offers a pizza experience that’s both satisfying and sustainably minded. It’s no wonder this spot has become a favorite among Iowa City’s pizza enthusiasts on Reddit.

Pagliai’s Pizza

When it comes to classic, no-fuss pizza, Pagliai’s Pizza has firmly established itself as a cornerstone of Iowa City’s pizza landscape. This family-owned gem has been delighting locals for decades, and Reddit users can’t stop singing its praises. Step into Pagliai’s and you’ll immediately be charmed by its old-school, cozy vibe that perfectly complements its straightforward yet delicious offerings. For those who crave a traditional, no-frills pizza that’s consistently great, Pagliai’s is a must-visit in Iowa City. The legacy and quality of this beloved pizzeria make it a standout choice for any pizza lover.

Mesa Pizza

Mesa Pizza stands out in Iowa City for its bold and imaginative offerings that cater to a wide range of tastes. This energetic spot is beloved by Reddit users for its extensive menu that pushes the boundaries of traditional pizza. Walk in and you’re met with a lively, welcoming vibe that’s perfect for a casual meal with friends or a quick bite after a night out. A popular choice is their BBQ chicken pineapple pizza. This option strikes a delightful balance with its tangy barbecue sauce, tender chicken pieces, and a hint of smokiness. The flavor profile is both complex and satisfying, making it a favorite among those looking for something beyond the usual pizza toppings. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, the welcoming environment makes it easy to feel right at home. The innovative menu and inviting setting make Mesa Pizza a top recommendation for pizza lovers in Iowa City.

Read more: The 5 best pizzas in Des Moines, according to our readers

This story was generated in part by AI and edited by The Iowa Starting Line staff.