
Sen. Sandy Salmon at the subcommittee to potentially expose drag performances to obscentiy lawsuits. (Nikoel Hytrek/Iowa Starting Line)
Republicans are pushing to open obscenity laws in hopes of making it easier to sue drag performers.
Senate File 116, a bill that follows long-time efforts by Republicans to ban drag shows, was passed through a subcommittee Wednesday.
Sen. Sandy Salmon (R-Janesville) who has led the anti-drag show push over the years, explicitly said she brought the bill forward because constituents complained they can’t sue over drag performances because they don’t meet the definition of obscenity.
Keenan Crow is the director of policy and advocacy for One Iowa, a statewide LGBTQ rights organization. Crow said the main danger of the bill is that it allows people to sue for anything they might deem obscene, even if it doesn’t match the bill’s definition.
“The biggest concern with this piece of legislation is not so much the definition anymore. It’s this private cause of action that is going to allow people with deep pockets to harass venues that have no budget to defend themselves against these baseless lawsuits,” they said.
The real goal of the bill, Crow said, is to create a “chilling effect” on any business that might host a drag show or do an event featuring a drag performer.
The bill prohibits “exposing” people under 18 to “obscene performances” or “admitting” people under 18 to a location that hosts “obscene performances.”
A similar bill was introduced in 2023, but the definition of obscenity then was so broad it could have applied to plays and musicals, the circus, or other live activities where people use costumes and makeup.
The current bill allows parents to file a lawsuit to determine obscenity, which means a judge will decide whether something is obscene, but it will require going through the court process.
Anita Fischer an activist for Protect My Innocence, an anti-LGBTQ organization based out of Pella, explicitly mentioned drag queen story hours as events that should be shut down.
“Drag story hour advertises itself as an enriching, kid friendly activity for the entire family to enjoy, but in fact has become a safe haven for predators at a time that is used for advocating sexual confusion,” she said.
“No normal adult would have any desire to act or dress inappropriately in front of children, and we as taxpayers should not have our money used to sexually indoctrinate our youth via performances or materials,” she continued. “This has nothing to do with hate. This is about protecting children.”
The majority of people at the subcommittee opposed the bill because it opens the door to frivolous lawsuits and harassment of LGBTQ spaces.
Elizabeth Hall, a local trans woman, said the language scares her and other trans people she knows. She pointed out how supporters of the bill seemed happy to go further and to restrict how trans people can appear in society.
“And that’s pretty thinly veiled language attacking us,” Hall said. “It’s there to push us back into the closet, make our existence publicly as untenable and as difficult as possible.”
Republican Sens. Jeff Taylor of Sioux Center and Cherielynn Westrich of Ottumwa passed the bill. Both senators also introduced the bill.
Sen. Janice Weiner, a Democrat from Iowa City, did not support the bill.
The bill now goes on to be discussed in the full committee, potentially with some tweaks to the language.
Support Our Cause
Thank you for taking the time to read our work. Before you go, we hope you'll consider supporting our values-driven journalism, which has always strived to make clear what's really at stake for Iowans and our future.
Since day one, our goal here at Iowa Starting Line has always been to empower people across the state with fact-based news and information. We believe that when people are armed with knowledge about what's happening in their local, state, and federal governments—including who is working on their behalf and who is actively trying to block efforts aimed at improving the daily lives of Iowan families—they will be inspired to become civically engaged.


Here’s why Iowa students won’t have new Title IX protections
Iowa students, including transgender and nonbinary children, will not enjoy new federal Title IX protections at school because Iowa Attorney General...

Celebrate Pride Month with these must-read books
We asked our colleagues across Courier Newsroom to share recommendations for books by LGBTQ+ authors. Here’s what they said. Reading allows us to...

New Pride mural in Des Moines to ‘roll out the welcome mat’ for LGBTQ+ community
A new mural has opened in Des Moines' East Village to emphasize the city welcomes the LGBTQ+ community. For weeks, four corners at the intersection...

22 LGBTQ+ Pride events in Iowa (3 brand new!) in 2024
June is LGBTQ+ Pride Month. If you're looking for Pride events in Iowa in 2024, here are 22 of them. The first Pride was in 1970, on the one-year...

Grants for Iowa LGBTQ+ businesses now open; here’s how to apply
Money is now available for LGBTQ+-owned or allied businesses in Iowa. A new grant program to support LGBTQ+ owned restaurants and bars has now...

Iowa joins lawsuit against feds over protections for LGBTQ students
New Title IX rules clarify that “sex discrimination” applies to discrimination based on gender identity. Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds and Attorney General...