Accusations Counted Against Iowa Schools In ‘Divisive Concepts’ Reporting Bill

Screenshot of Feb. 1 of Iowa House Education Subcommittee hearing.

Concerns were raised today about a House Republican bill that would create a system to report educators for teaching banned “divisive concepts” from a new law—which can include forms of racism and sexism—in Iowa public schools and that would also levy fines on school districts where it was proven to have taken place.

During a Wednesday House Education Subcommittee hearing on House Study Bill 112, Michelle Johnson, a lobbyist for the Iowa Association of School Boards, noted a few issues her organization has with the proposal.

“The report that’s required to be filed with the General Assembly includes districts with a potential violation, so it’s kind of just predetermined that the district did something bad,” Johnson said. “It’s kind of biasing people against the district that there is any wrongdoing before it’s proven.”

Advertise on Iowa Starting Line

All the reports of potential violations are to be submitted to the Iowa Legislature in an annual report due on July 1. The report would indicate the school district where each potential violation occurred, so even if a district’s name is cleared during an investigation it would still be listed.

Rep. Steve Holt (R-Denison) chaired the subcommittee and said while he can understand the concern with that provision, he supports keeping it in place.

“If you were to look at how a school district that had 200 potential violations, that might tell you something,” Holt said. “We all know the difference between potential and confirmed, but I think also if you see a school district that just seems to have a lot of potential violations, that tells you something too.”

Once a report is filed, the Iowa Department of Education will make a determination as to whether or not it is valid. If it is valid, the department would notify the local school board, which then has 14 days after the notice of noncompliance to correct the violation.

If the school board does not rectify the violation, the school district will be assessed a civil penalty between $500 to $5,000. Revenue from the penalties would go to the state general fund.

Outside of assigning investigations of potential violations to the Iowa Department of Education, the bill does not specify how such investigations are to be conducted nor is there a process to allow school districts to challenge allegations.

“We think that districts should be given a reasonable time to investigate and then contest that allegation if they think that’s reasonable,” Johnson said. “And we just think that districts should be given away to appeal these allegations as well.”

All suspected violations would be reported directly to the Iowa Department of Education’s website. Eric St. Clair, a lobbyist for the state agency, said this is a potential administrative issue with its current resources.

“Establishing and maintaining a system and the capacity to respond quickly to the alleged complaints that we receive through the system, it would be administratively cumbersome,” he said. 

“Without additional financial support and authority to support the program, we don’t think we could do this on a timeline that’s adequate for response to the public. 

St. Clair also said there are already reporting processes in place through the Iowa Board of Educational Examiners and this would create redundancies.

Holt and two speakers who supported the bill said this step was necessary because they believe school districts are finding a way to skirt the divisive concepts law by using language that wasn’t prohibited in it. The divisive concepts law was signed by Gov. Kim Reynolds in June 2021 to limit how public schools and state entities can offer training on racism, sexism, and diversity and inclusion.

“It would appear to us that this hasn’t been complied with in some school districts, that it has been blatantly ignored in some school districts, or that they’re simply trying to play word games and keep doing the same thing,” Holt said.

Holt and Rep. Skyler Wheeler (R-Hull), who introduced the bill, voted to advance it to the full House Education Committee while Rep. Sue Cahill (D-Marshalltown) voted against it.


by Ty Rushing

Advertise on Iowa Starting Line

If you enjoy stories like these, make sure to sign up for Iowa Starting Line’s main newsletter and/or our working class-focused Worker’s Almanac newsletter.

To contact Senior Editor Ty Rushing for tips or story ideas, email him at or find him on social media @Rushthewriter

​​Iowa Starting Line is part of an independent news network and focuses on how state and national decisions impact Iowans’ daily lives. We rely on your financial support to keep our stories free for all to read. You can contribute to us here. Also follow us on Facebook and Twitter.

2 Comments on "Accusations Counted Against Iowa Schools In ‘Divisive Concepts’ Reporting Bill"

  • How does this bill make education better?

    How does this decrease the stress level on educators?

    I coached and taught in Iowa for 32 years. I wonder if reading first hand accounts of slavery, Native Americans kids taken to boarding schools, and W. E. B. DuBois’ writings about “veil” of being Black would earn me a report or two?

    Students in my debate program this years are running all kinds of arguments. Would they be banned?
    1) Settler Colonialism
    2) Capitalism is the root of all evil
    3) All immigration should be allowed – the topic is about open borders for human migration.
    4) Populism is a form of fascism
    5) Election deniers hurt American democracy
    6) Climate change
    7) Asylum seekers deserve respect
    8) All human beings have equal moral worth – can’t believe that would be on a list
    9) Right to work is evil

    So many more that are probably on someone’s naughty list. Would my principal tell me to stop? Parents? Grand parents?

    Anyone can report for any reason, and every report has to be filed. WTH!

    Our educators need help, not more condemnation. They are dealing with kids that have been through a traumatic experience with Covid-19, and our entire society seems to be attacking our public schools. They need support. We need to figure out how to decrease the stress levels of all people in education. These idiotic proposals just increase the stress without working toward any solution.

    If you can, reach out to educators. February is the longest month in education. Then, call the legislators and try to find a way to have common cause to stop attacks on educators.

    I live in Washington now, and the teachers are not under daily attacks by their legislators. It’s still a tough time, and the teachers are hurting. I can’t imagine what it is like in the classroom or the principal’s office in Iowa right now.

  • After reading and listening the slew of bills pushed out by our Republican legislature these past weeks I have questions. Does real life or facts scare the bejezus out of you or what? Are you so unsure of your own parenting skills that you fear everything? And to all those screaming about how it should be for every person according to you–then do not ask me to pay for that education. Education entails being and learning to thrive in all scenarios, being able to have disagreements without violence or shaming. That is the real world and what parent ever would wish to hold their child back from having access to all information to help them into their future lives.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *