
The Supreme Court of the United States is expected to decide tomorrow whether the Trump Administration can add a question to the census asking about respondents’ citizenship, a decision that will impact some communities in Iowa.
If the question is added to the 2020 census, households and communities with undocumented immigrants will face a hard decision. Answer honestly or decline the opportunity to be counted as part of a city’s population.
In Iowa, most new immigrants are concentrated in the western part of the state where meatpacking businesses like Tyson Foods and Seaboard Triumph Foods operate and employ both documented and undocumented workers.
According to data from the Pew Research Center, Iowa’s population of undocumented immigrants for 2017 was around 50,000 people. This number has been slowly rising since the 1990s, but it slowed to a near-crawl in the mid-2000s.
Rep. Steve King has represented the Northwestern area of Iowa for nearly two decades, and he has long supported a question about citizenship being added to the census.
In a statement posted to his official website, King said, “Census data is used for a variety of reasons, including the apportionment of Congressional seats. Sanctuary states like California flaunt federal immigration law to give aid and comfort to large populations of illegal aliens, and those states are unjustly rewarded with extra Congressional representation as a byproduct of doing so.”
In February 2018, King sent a letter to the Department of Commerce calling for the addition of a citizenship question to the census. The letter was cosigned by several fellow House members.
However, for Iowa’s congressional districts, it would likely be King’s district that would be impacted the most by an undercount of immigrants.
Mark Prosser, the police chief of Storm Lake, said having an undercount on the census means a city has less revenue, grant money and, down the road, money for important services.
“We know that a substantial number of our community hasn’t responded to the census in the past,” he said. “That’s why we’re hoping to get a more accurate count in 2020.”
Prosser said when money is distributed based on an official number of people, but the actual population is higher, the money automatically isn’t enough to cover a community’s needs.
Having an accurate census number would immediately make a difference in the support for necessary services, he said.
He mentioned the Iowa road use tax that gets distributed to communities for anything road-related like street departments and snow removal.
[inline-ad id=”0″]
Many immigrants call Northwest Iowa home, and Prosser said he knows that the number includes people with and without documentation. He also said he knows many of those people don’t understand the confidentiality of the census, and they come from places where government counts are threatening.
Prosser said a question asking about citizenship wouldn’t help because it’s hard enough to get people to participate.
The concern about asking for people’s citizenship status is that those who are undocumented, or have family or friends who are undocumented, will be too scared of being tracked by immigration authorities to respond and therefore won’t be counted.
“I think that’s a rational, understandable fear,” Prosser said.
But there are other consequences of people being afraid to call attention to themselves, like when it comes to reporting crimes.
“We are always working from a public safety standpoint,” Prosser said. “When we have people worried … they fade into the shadows.”
Some say that’s the point of the proposed addition: to skew population numbers in communities that tend to vote for Democrats. Lower populations would result in less funding, research and, possibly change a state’s number of House members in Congress. It could also allow districts to be drawn in Republicans’ favor, though possibly not in Iowa.
That issue of representation is King’s main concern.
“Citizens should not have their representation in Congress diluted due to the concentrated presence of illegal aliens in lawless cities and states,” King said in the statement on his website. “Americans should count the citizenship question as a partial win, while demanding more action to prevent illegal aliens from determining Congressional seats.”
Yesterday, the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth District sent the case back to a Maryland judge who wants to reopen the question of whether the Trump Administration had discriminatory intent in proposing this question. However, most expect the Supreme Court to hand down its decision on Thursday.
by Nikoel Hytrek
Posted 6/26/19
Support Our Cause
Thank you for taking the time to read our work. Before you go, we hope you'll consider supporting our values-driven journalism, which has always strived to make clear what's really at stake for Iowans and our future.
Since day one, our goal here at Iowa Starting Line has always been to empower people across the state with fact-based news and information. We believe that when people are armed with knowledge about what's happening in their local, state, and federal governments—including who is working on their behalf and who is actively trying to block efforts aimed at improving the daily lives of Iowan families—they will be inspired to become civically engaged.


Lanon Baccam wins 3rd District Dem primary, will face Zach Nunn
Baccam defeats Melissa Vine to challenge Republican incumbent Lanon Baccam defeated Melissa Vine in Tuesday’s Democratic primary for Iowa’s 3rd...

Hardin County man running for office as Trump-loving Democrat to local party’s dismay
Brad Rewoldt, who recently changed his party affiliation from Republican, says his support of Trump will probably 'piss off' Democrats There is a...

Scheetz: Tax cuts for all Iowans, not just the wealthy
State Rep. Sami Scheetz says all Iowans should benefit from tax cuts via a sales tax reduction As a state representative, my job is to serve the...

Kalbach: What Iowa Republicans focused on during legislative session
Our state legislative session finished up towards the end of April, and I’m glad it’s over! From further de-funding and privatizing our public...

Advocates file suit to stop Iowa’s ‘unconstitutional’ immigration law
Immigration advocates filed a federal lawsuit Thursday to stop Iowa’s new immigration law—SF 2340—from taking effect arguing that the legislation...

Iowa Republicans make outlawing gay marriage key 2024 campaign priority
Iowa Republicans have made outlawing gay marriage a key goal in their 2024 party platform. During the Iowa GOP’s 2024 state convention on Saturday,...