Guest post by Allison Engel, an Iowa State University graduate, has worked in higher education for the past 12 years.
Yes, Gov. Reynolds, let’s talk about U.S. News & World Report rankings. But not the livability rankings, which do not include data from all 50 states in all categories. In this blinkered competition, Iowa snagged the No. 1 spot, including the top ranking for infrastructure.
This must have come as a surprise to those who read the recent Federal Highway Administration report that Iowa has the most structurally deficient bridges in the nation, as well as one of the country’s largest collections of poor roads.
And, as a Sept. 6 article in the Register noted, there were some glaring inconsistencies in the livability statistics. “For example,” the story read, “Iowa was given a first-place ranking for its high school graduation rate but placed 33rd in college readiness. The state was in the top 10 for preschool enrollment but finished in the bottom half for pre-K quality.”
The U.S. News & World Report rankings we should be looking at are the ones for our state universities. Here, sadly, the University of Iowa and Iowa State University have suffered serious declines during the Branstad-Reynolds administration.
In 2015, the U of I was ranked 71st among national universities, a group that includes both public and private schools offering a full range of undergraduate majors and master’s and doctoral programs. This year, it is 89th – a drop of 18 places in four years. In 2015, ISU was ranked 106th among national universities. This year it was tied for 119th – a drop of 13 places in four years. The University of Northern Iowa is not included in the U.S. News national university rankings.
(Note: for past years’ rankings, you must Google U.S. News & World Report annual rankings for each year, and then search for Iowa State and Iowa.)
Under the last Democratic administration, in 2008, both the University of Iowa and Iowa State were ranked significantly higher. In 2008, Iowa was ranked 64th among national universities. ISU was ranked 85th. Compared to 2019, that’s a drop of 25 places and 34 places, respectively.
Yikes. At a university not in Iowa, I’ve seen administrators have major meltdowns after dropping one place in the rankings.
These rankings, as disliked as they are by some educators, matter in terms of reputation, faculty hiring and quality of applicants. They are routinely consulted by prospective students – particularly by those paying full tuition from other states – to decide what schools they want to attend.
The rankings use information submitted by participating schools, but also include reputational measures. Basically, deans are asked to rank their peers on their academic reputation. So, the U of I and ISU are seen by their peers as slipping.
Why? Well, in the past year and a half, Gov. Reynolds has presided over millions of dollars in cuts to the three state universities. Some of these cuts were made after the universities already had set their budgets, which is no way to run a railroad.
University of Iowa president Bruce Harreld placed the blame squarely on funding woes. “Those rankings are a stark illustration of what happens when there’s not enough investment in higher education by the state and by students and their parents,” he told the Register the week after the 2019 rankings were released.
It is dismaying to watch university hiring and salary freezes take effect, and academic centers close. As a result, our exceptional professors and researchers are getting picked off by well-endowed private universities that can offer more stability, better facilities and higher salaries. People our universities once promoted with pride are now bringing acclaim to other institutions elsewhere.
So, Gov. Reynolds, don’t place too much stock in the livability ranking. It was based on statistics compiled before the last legislative session ended, when you and other Republicans gave an unprecedented tax cut to the wealthy. It did not take into account the undeserved 7.5 percent bonus your administration just shoveled to the out-of-state insurance companies who now oversee Medicaid and are depriving untold numbers of Iowa’s 685,000 poor and disabled citizens of adequate medical care.
Instead, I’d like to hear you explain the steep drop in the U.S. News rankings for the University of Iowa and Iowa State during your tenure.
by Allison Engel